Regardless of whether the credits represent taxable income, loans or transfers between the taxpayer’s own bank accounts, whether within the same bank or between different banks, SARS expects taxpayers to account for transactions where total banking credits exceed declared income. This places a substantial administrative burden on taxpayers, who may be required to reconstruct an entire year’s banking activity, identify transfers between accounts and explain transactions that do not necessarily constitute taxable income.
‘Next-Level Scrutiny’— SARS Means Business
In cases such as these, which appear to be particularly prevalent among high-net-worth individuals with multiple bank accounts and substantial banking activity, SARS is effectively saying that where total banking credits exceed the income declared in a tax return, the apparent discrepancy must be explained, and extensively so.
The communication from SARS reads: “Our records indicate that credits totalling [rand amount] were deposited into bank account(s) held in your name during the 2026 year of assessment. These amounts do not reconcile with income of [rand amount] declared in your income tax return.”
SARS says, to finalise its verification, it requires A4 copies of:
- Schedule/breakdown/ledger of all deposits made into the taxpayer’s bank account(s), also clarifying whether the deposit is an income, loan or interbank transfer.
- For all deposits that are not loans or interbank transfer, the source of income is required.
- Loan agreements should be provided for all loan deposits.
- Detailed explanations should be provided for all interbank transfers.
- 12 months bank statement(s) confirming the deposits made.
Although SARS has the right and is empowered under section 46 of the Tax Administration Act 28 of 2011 to request relevant material for purposes of tax administration, these powers are not unlimited. The information requested must be foreseeably relevant, and taxpayers must be afforded a reasonable period within which to respond.
Nevertheless, such extensive requests can place a taxpayer’s life on hold. Reconciling a whole year’s banking activity is an enormous undertaking, particularly for individuals operating multiple accounts and frequently transferring funds between them. In some instances, SARS does not even identify which accounts have triggered the verification, leaving taxpayers to investigate their current, savings, bond, investment and even credit card accounts to establish the source of the apparent discrepancy.
If SARS’ requests go unanswered or are not adequately addressed, taxpayers risk facing further enquiries, additional assessments or, where the statutory requirements are met, estimated assessments under section 95 of the Tax Administration Act. However, SARS must comply with the applicable procedural requirements, and taxpayers retain their rights to challenge disputable assessments through the prescribed objection and appeal processes. The consequences of an inadequate response can nevertheless be costly and time-consuming.
Remember, SARS asks the questions, but taxpayers generally bear the burden under section 102(1)(a) of the Tax Administration Act of proving that an amount is exempt or otherwise not taxable. This makes credible explanations and supporting documentation essential, although SARS itself remains subject to statutory evidentiary obligations, including establishing the reasonableness of an estimated assessment under section 102(2).
Court Ruling Reinforces the Principle
A February 2025 Tax Court ruling in SARS’ favour in Taxpayer D v CSARS (IT 35476) illustrates the consequences of failing to satisfactorily substantiate the source and nature of substantial financial transactions. Although the case concerned unexplained increases in shareholder loan account balances, rather than routine personal banking verification, it reinforces the importance of maintaining credible supporting documentation when SARS questions the tax treatment of funds.
The case involved a successful businessman who was the sole shareholder and director of several companies. SARS challenged substantial increases in shareholder loan account balances, which it said were unsupported by the income declared in his tax returns. The taxpayer was assessed on R37.1 million in undeclared income and a further R20 million in undeclared interest income, bringing the total disputed amount to R57.1 million.
SARS said Taxpayer D gave inconsistent explanations for the cause of the unexplained increases in the balances of the loan accounts. The amounts were not supported by the income declared in Taxpayer D’s returns.
The Tax Court ultimately ruled in SARS’ favour, with the taxpayer’s inconsistent explanations and inadequate supporting evidence proving particularly damaging to his case. The judgment reinforces the importance of substantiating the true nature of financial transactions, particularly where SARS alleges that substantial amounts constitute undeclared taxable income.
A Result of SARS’ Increased Adoption of Technology and Third-party Data
SARS’ increasingly extensive verification approach coincides with its growing reliance on technology, data analytics and third-party reporting to identify potential tax discrepancies. Banks report financial information to SARS, enabling the revenue authority to identify apparent differences between declared income and banking activity. However, transfers between accounts can inflate aggregate banking credits without generating additional taxable income. A bank deposit is not automatically taxable income, and the underlying nature of the transaction remains fundamental to determining its correct tax treatment.
Technology enables SARS to identify apparent discrepancies by comparing declared income with banking information obtained from third parties. However, such comparisons do not necessarily distinguish between taxable receipts, loans, capital movements and transfers of funds already accounted for. Consequently, taxpayers may find themselves having to explain transactions that do not represent undeclared income in the first place.
Whether SARS should adopt a more targeted approach, identifying specific transactions requiring clarification rather than demanding exhaustive reconciliations of an entire year’s banking activity, is a question for another day. But, while SARS is entitled to investigate potential discrepancies, the administrative burden imposed on compliant taxpayers should remain reasonable and proportionate to the information genuinely required.
Be Careful How You Respond to SARS’ Questions
Taxpayers who receive these detailed requests from SARS, should pay attention to how they respond because getting it wrong, can have costly consequences.
Explanations should properly address SARS’ verification queries and, wherever possible, be supported by credible documentary evidence. Where taxpayers cannot satisfactorily explain substantial deposits or credits, they may face further investigation and potentially additional or estimated assessments, subject to the applicable statutory requirements.
The ever-growing extensive nature of SARS’ verification requests demonstrates that taxpayers must be prepared to substantiate the nature and source of funds moving through their bank accounts. There is, nevertheless, an important distinction between identifying genuine, undeclared income and requiring compliant taxpayers to explain every movement of money between their own accounts.