SARS is increasingly using third-party information to identify tax non-compliance before taxpayers even know they are under scrutiny. With penalties reaching up to 200% and criminal prosecution a real possibility, taxpayers with undisclosed tax defaults may be running out of time to come clean on their own terms.
In its media release, SARS has issued another stark warning to taxpayers, revealing that its expanding use of third-party data has uncovered significant potential tax irregularities among businesses supplying goods and services to government.
While these discrepancies do not automatically establish tax evasion or even incorrect declarations, the announcement sends an unmistakable message: SARS is increasingly capable of identifying potential non-compliance without relying on taxpayers to disclose it.
For taxpayers sitting on historic tax defaults, the implications extend well beyond government suppliers.
SARS Already Has the Information
Traditionally, taxpayers may have assumed that undeclared income, inaccurate returns or historic tax irregularities would remain undetected unless SARS initiated an audit.
That assumption is becoming increasingly dangerous. SARS’s latest announcement demonstrates how information obtained from third parties can be cross-referenced against taxpayers’ declarations to identify inconsistencies warranting further investigation.
In this instance, government payment records were compared against VAT returns, exposing thousands of potential discrepancies. This increasingly aggressive approach is consistent with SARS’s longstanding strategic objective of making tax compliance easy, while ensuring that non-compliance becomes progressively more difficult and costly.
In the latest media release, SARS Commissioner Dr Johnstone Makhubu reiterated this position, stating that SARS would continue to make compliance “simple and easy”, while acting “decisively against wilful non-compliance”.
This is more than a policy statement. SARS’s growing reliance on third-party information, targeted enforcement and increasingly sophisticated data analysis demonstrates that this strategy is being actively implemented.
For taxpayers with historic tax defaults, the message is particularly significant: SARS is making it easier to comply, but increasingly expensive to be caught failing to do so.
The Voluntary Disclosure Window Is Not Unlimited
For taxpayers who have previously failed to declare income, understated their tax liabilities or submitted inaccurate returns, the Voluntary Disclosure Programme (“VDP”) statutory remedy remains one of the most important mechanisms for regularising their affairs.
Established under sections 225 to 233 of the TAA, the programme allows qualifying taxpayers to disclose historic tax defaults in exchange for substantial relief from understatement penalties and protection against criminal prosecution for the disclosed defaults.
However, there is a critical requirement that taxpayers frequently overlook.
Under section 227(a), a valid disclosure must be voluntary. This means that taxpayers cannot simply assume they will qualify for VDP relief after SARS has already uncovered their non-compliance.
Although section 226 provides limited circumstances in which a disclosure may still qualify following notification of an audit or investigation, this is subject to SARS’s discretion and specific statutory requirements.
Given the increasingly narrow window within which taxpayers may qualify for voluntary disclosure relief, early intervention and a carefully considered legal strategy are critical. Engaging a multidisciplinary team comprising experienced tax attorneys, tax practitioners and chartered accountants can make a material difference in identifying historic tax exposure, assessing eligibility for VDP relief and developing a defensible disclosure strategy. Importantly, this process should commence before SARS initiates enquiries that could potentially compromise the voluntary nature of the disclosure.
A taxpayer who waits until SARS identifies a discrepancy, commences an investigation or confronts them with evidence of undeclared income may therefore find that the opportunity for voluntary disclosure has been severely compromised.
Importantly, the mere fact that SARS possesses third-party information does not automatically disqualify a taxpayer from VDP relief. The timing, circumstances and genuine voluntariness of the disclosure remain crucial.
The Cost of Getting Caught Can Be Severe
The financial consequences of tax non-compliance can extend considerably beyond the original tax liability.
Under section 222, read with the understatement penalty table in section 223 of the TAA, SARS may impose substantial penalties depending on the taxpayer’s conduct.
In standard cases, these penalties include:
- 10% for a substantial understatement;
- 25% where reasonable care was not taken in completing a return;
- 50% where there were no reasonable grounds for the tax position adopted;
- 75% for an impermissible avoidance arrangement;
- 100% for gross negligence; and
- 150% for intentional tax evasion.
Where the taxpayer’s conduct is obstructive or constitutes a repeat case, these penalties can increase to 200%.
These penalties are calculated with reference to the statutory tax shortfall and can be imposed in addition to the underlying tax liability and applicable interest.
By contrast, qualifying voluntary disclosures made before notification of an audit or criminal investigation can reduce understatement penalties to 0% for the first four categories, 5% for gross negligence and 10% for intentional tax evasion.
The difference can be enormous. A taxpayer facing a potential 150% or even 200% understatement penalty for intentional tax evasion could, where all VDP requirements are satisfied, potentially reduce that penalty to 10%.
That is not merely a compliance benefit. It can fundamentally change the financial consequences of historic non-compliance.
Criminal Prosecution: The Risk Beyond Financial Penalties
Perhaps more concerning is that certain tax defaults can also expose taxpayers to criminal prosecution.
Section 234 of the TAA criminalises specified acts of non-compliance, including certain failures to submit returns, retain records, provide information or disclose material facts. Depending on the particular offence, wilful or negligent conduct may result in a fine or imprisonment for up to two years.
More serious conduct falls under section 235, which addresses intentional tax evasion and fraudulent attempts to obtain undue refunds.
A person convicted under this provision may face a fine or imprisonment for a period not exceeding five years. These are not theoretical consequences. They are expressly provided for in South Africa’s tax legislation.
Crucially, section 229 of the TAA provides that SARS must not pursue criminal prosecution for a tax offence arising from a default validly disclosed under the VDP, subject to the statutory requirements. For taxpayers whose historic conduct may potentially constitute tax evasion, this protection can be considerably more valuable than the reduction in financial penalties.
The Time to Act Is Before SARS Comes Knocking
SARS’s latest announcement should not be viewed as an isolated crackdown only on government suppliers.
It illustrates a broader enforcement approach in which third-party information, data analysis and targeted compliance interventions are making it increasingly difficult for tax irregularities to remain undetected.
Taxpayers with undisclosed foreign income, undeclared investment returns, inaccurate VAT declarations, unreported business income or other historic tax defaults should urgently assess their exposure.
Not every discrepancy requires a VDP application, and not every taxpayer will qualify. In appropriate circumstances, an ordinary correction may suffice. However, where a genuine tax default exists, professional advice should be obtained before approaching SARS to determine the appropriate regularisation mechanism and preserve any available statutory relief.
The central lesson is simple: the VDP rewards taxpayers who come forward voluntarily. Waiting until SARS discovers the problem may turn an opportunity for relief into an expensive and potentially criminal tax dispute.
For taxpayers concerned about historic non-compliance, the time for a reactive approach has passed. Navigating the VDP process requires more than simply submitting outstanding returns or disclosing previously undeclared income. It demands a coordinated legal, tax and financial assessment to ensure that the disclosure is accurate, complete and strategically sound. The involvement of a skilled multidisciplinary team of tax attorneys, tax practitioners and chartered accountants is therefore essential to navigating the statutory requirements, managing potential exposure and securing the maximum relief lawfully available.
With SARS’s detection capabilities expanding, the question for non-compliant taxpayers is no longer simply whether SARS might discover their historic defaults. It is whether they will act before SARS does.